The "Right" Way

The other day, we bought Evan a bunch of stickers from the dollar store. When we got home, we would give him a couple, he’d stick them together, then ask for more. In my head – and even out loud once – I said “but you’re not using them right!”. Apparently, in my head, there are only specific ways one can use stickers correctly.
I had to bite my tongue and just let him play how he wanted. After all, we always say how we want to foster his curiosity and experimental side, as long as it’s free from danger. Also, what harm does it do if he doesn’t play “the right way” with the stickers?Β 
It’s funny how doing things “right” is so engrained in us.
Take the cake decorating class I’m in, for example. Each week, we learn how to do new designs using the different tips. Often, when I feel I’ve had enough practice, I’ll start playing around, seeing what else I can do. Or, I’ll try a different technique to achieve the same look. The teacher will come over and either tell me I’m “doing it wrong”, that “it looks awful”, or ask me “what the heck are you doing?”. I usually reply with “just experimenting – it’s okay! The world won’t end!” and keep going. She doesn’t often interact with me anymore.
Now, in a community class like this one, I don’t expect a high level of teaching. I know she’s not trained and is doing this as something fun to do on the side. It doesn’t bother me, because I know how unimportant the class is in the scheme of things. And I can also learn all the things she’s teaching without positive interaction with her (however, it is making me NOT want to show her a photo of the cake I decorated for Evan’s birthday).
But…transfer those same words to an elementary science or writing class, and you’ve got a serious problem. All of a sudden, you’re squashing that innate curiosity and need for exploration we are all born with. Students start following and memorizing the instructions like a recipe, without knowing why, and stop experimenting and asking questions.
This is why we can’t say “you’re not doing it right” to our children at this stage. However they want to play is their “right” way (again, as long as there is no danger to themselves or others). It’s their way of learning about the world around them, and they need to do so in a safe environment free from ridicule and correction.Β 
If we can do this for them, then – at the very least- when they’re in their 30s they’ll feel confident with experimenting with the #13 tip even if their decorating teacher tells them to stop.
Advertisements

Comments on: "The "Right" Way" (8)

  1. Your cake decorating teacher sounds like a beyotch, wow!

    I very much agree with your philosophy on this. I try to do the same thing in the classroom when there are multiple ways to get the same result. If there is a particular “right” way that I expect the kids to use, I make sure to explain why it is that way or why it's not another way so that they understand and it's not just a “do this” or “don't do that” type of situation. It's a much more positive and collaborative way to go about things.

    Like

  2. Can WE get to see a cake photo? I am in awe of real people who can make cakes look nice. Awe.

    Like

  3. OMG I can't believe your cake decorating teacher says those things to you!! COME. ON.

    ITA with you on letting kids use things in different/creative ways at this age. There will be plenty of time in the future when all they will want to do is conform πŸ˜‰

    Like

  4. Andrea – yeah, kinda don't get why she's teaching! Sounds like you use some good techniques in your classroom.

    Liberal Arts Lady – now I feel like if I post it, I'll disappoint! Here's the link: https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-2uV1WcTDr5Q/UIH4arnH6AI/AAAAAAAAHrE/u05M1JjNfqQ/s640/IMG_2849.JPG

    Ella – I know, right? She's that awful to everyone in the class! And good point about them WANTING to conform later in life πŸ˜‰

    Like

  5. I love this post!! This came up with Gabby and I the other day. She was trying to put her jacket on. She put it on the floor – upside down (so the collar was her feet). She stepped on it and went to put her arms in. I was like “gabby that's now how we put our jacket on” I stupidly made her pick it up and put it on “the right way”. Then the next day we were at daycare and she did the same thing, but I didn't catch it right away. She threw it over her head and put it on easier than the way I showed her. Who knew! Her teachers taught her a different way to do it.

    Great post!

    Like

  6. You did that cake? WOW! Awesome πŸ™‚

    I think you should stop listening to your teacher and go with your creativity.

    Like

  7. Thanks Chall! And, yeah, I don't listen to her at all πŸ™‚

    Like

  8. Jess – great story! It's funny how stuck in our ways we can be without even thinking of it πŸ˜€

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: